First meeting of UCI Independent Commission adjourned early due to lack of documents

From Reuters:

’s world governing body has yet to release any documents to the independent commission set up last year to investigate allegations over the doping scandal, a hearing was told on Friday.

“It amazes me that we’ve had no documents whatsoever,” Britain’s 11-times Paralympic champion Tanni Grey-Thompson, one of the three members on the commission, told counsel Ian Mill.

Mill also told the hearing that a date for a commission hearing set provisionally for April 9-26 would need to be rescheduled.

Friday’s hearing was intended to set up the procedures, fix a timetable and set a date for a hearing. However, it hit immediate stumbling blocks and was adjourned to Jan. 31.

Mill said there had been “no desire to suppress or conceal any documents”, with 16 files of material available, but cast doubt on the commission’s need for them, with the possibility of a broader ‘truth and reconciliation’ hearing being set up with other bodies.

In increasingly testy exchanges between the commission members and the lawyer, it was made clear that the process could take up to two years, if the commission were not suspended entirely.

Mill said it was clear in any case that it would not be possible for the proposed April hearing to go ahead and a report would not be ready for June.

Responding to concern expressed by the independent commission chair Philip Otton, who had expressed a fear that allegations against the risked being “kicked into the long grass”, Mill said: “We’re not trying to kill this enquiry, we set you up.”

“Now you want to knock us down,” said Otton, before withdrawing the comment.

After a 45 minute break, Otton told the hearing that the had agreed to make documents available to the Commission and the hearing was adjourning “with considerable reluctance”. Next week’s hearing will decide how to proceed.

“On that occasion, we will consider whether or not the Commission will continue on the present timetable,” he said.


Otton said it was “blindingly obvious” that there was immense public interest in determining why and how Armstrong’s U.S. Postal Service team was able to engage in systematic doping without detection or sanction.

Armstrong has been stripped of his seven Tour de France titles after a report, that included testimony from former team mates, revealed what it called “the most sophisticated, professionalised and successful doping programe that sport has ever seen.”

The , who dope tested Armstrong 218 times without a positive result, set up its independent commission to investigate allegations made against it in the affair.

Mill said the was open to a truth and reconciliation process, with the and the US anti-doping agency , but subject to changes to the code to allow an amnesty to be offered to those testifying.

“The has accepted that a truth and reconciliation process was one they wish to engage with, notwithstanding that it was limited to the problems of doping in the sport of ,” he said.

has accepted that it’s code would require to be changed so as to enable the sort of amnesty to be offered which would be likely to result in important evidence being made available.

“We have asked to tell us how and when such a change to the code can be achieved.”

Mill said the independent commission appeared to envisage such a truth and reconciliation process forming part of their enquiry, but that might not be the case.

“That was not what this (independent) enquiry was designed to do,” he said, pointing out that the had spent a considerable sum on the commission and funding another longer and broader one was beyond the resources of the alone.

“If others, in particular , are being asked for help to fund the process then they have to have the opportunity to discuss and agree with us the process itself and we envisage that,” added the lawyer.

“It therefore does not follow that this commission will ultimately be involved in that process.” (Editing by John Mehaffey)

About Ron 3383 Articles
Ron Callahan is the chief cook and bottlewasher at Bike World News, doing everything from website design to bike reviews.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.